Total Pageviews

Follow by Email

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Mamata goes the Left way


By Swapan Dasgupta

There are few politicians who have made the journey from the sublime to the ridiculous in so short a time as West Bengal’s Mamata Banerjee. A year ago, as the well-entrenched Left Front Government floundered, the leader of the Trinamool Congress emerged as a Mother Goddess, hell bent on slaying the Marxist demons who had intimidated an entire people for three decades.

It is not that everyone regarded Mamata as the perfect avenger. Her temperamental ways, her inability to treat colleagues as equals and her determination to wage total war on her opponents regardless of the issues did arouse fears. However, since taking on the CPI(M) unflinchingly and unwaveringly for a sustained period required exceptional determination, Bengalis were inclined to allow Mamata an exceptional degree of license. After all, it was said, you had to be slightly crazy to take on the Left in an apparently unequal war.

A Bengal that elected Mamata with a staggering majority in May last year was always a bit wary of her ability to make the transition from rebel to Chief Minister. However, the fact that she came to power on the crest of popular goodwill, the blessings of the middle classes, the unequivocal support of the Muslim minority and even the endorsement of the over-unionised labour suggested that her ‘poriborton’ (change) journey would involve a balanced approach. Above all, the real expectation from Mamata was that she would put an end to the petty tyranny of the CPI(M)’s fabled ‘cadre raj’. In short, having experimented with quasi-radicalism for 35 years, Mamata would strive to steer West Bengal in the direction of normal politics. West Bengal was tired of being the permanent contrarian.

It has taken less than a year for disappointment to overwhelm the state. Far from abandoning reckless populism and getting down to the serious business of governance, Didi appears to frittering away her energies in trivial pursuits. Whether it is the curious decision to paint large parts of Kolkata blue, a silly prosecution of a middle class professor who had forwarded a cartoon on email and her diktat to her supporters to shun all social contacts with CPI(M) supporters, Mamata has focussed attention on her eccentric ways. Coupled with her peremptory treatment of party colleagues who dared to be a little different, she seems hell bent on making governance in West Bengal over the next four years a Mad Hatter’s Party.

The natural rebel in Mamata appears to have snuffed out her momentary inclination to emerge as a statesman, with one finger in national politics. It is true that the local media, particularly that section which endorsed her enthusiastically in her battle against the Left Front, has been merciless in the attacks on her. But far from viewing criticism as a wake-up call, a beleaguered Mamata has been quick to detect conspiracies. Why the rape of a girl in a posh area of Kolkata or the assault of a college principal in North Bengal should be evidence of a monumental gang-up to destabilise her government is a matter of mystery.

What is not bewildering is the fact that the Chief Minister has unwittingly borrowed the language and the imagery of the very Left she claims to despise. The incessant talk of conspiracies is so reminiscent of a Left which had grown up on a diet of counter-revolutionary paranoia. Conspiracy or ‘chakranta’ was a favourite term of the Stalin lovers who spent the first two decades of Left Front rule declaiming against a diabolical Centre.

Likewise, the social boycott of the CPI(M) that Mamata has begun advocating is borrowed almost entirely from her Communist foes. The cadre raj that was unleashed in Bengal by the CPI(M) did not always generate physical violence. The strategy of the comrades also consisted of enforcing social ostracism of a target, denying him labour, livelihood and community services till the point where the victim either left the locality or grovelled before the party Local Committee. For the Left, which believed in a total control of society, social boycott was a lethal and effective weapon. It yielded results but it was also responsible for the anti-Left backlash that found expression after the Lok Sabha election of 2009.

It is this unthinking drift to copy-cat Leftist politics that is at the heart of Mamata’s woes. Sometime in the early-1990s, Mamata arrived at the conclusion that the old-style blend of bhadralok and jotedar (petty landlord) politics would not suffice to oust the Left. Like the Congress of Siddharth Shankar Ray that matched Left-wing extremism of the CPI(M) and Naxalites with Indira Gandhi’s radical rhetoric, Mamata chose to beat the Left at its own game. It paid rich dividends and her unrelenting opposition to muscular land acquisition in Nandigram and Singur secured for her the support of Left-inclined intellectuals who glorify poverty and loath development.  

No doubt the CPI(M)’s loss of monopoly control over Leftist rhetoric played a role in the electoral transformation of Bengal. But where Mamata seems to have miscalculated is in believing that the cussedness and obstructive ways of the Left is a source of inspiration to Bengal. That may have been the case a decade ago but the poriborton people voted for in 2011 was meant to usher in liberation from economic stagnation and despondency. Mamata doesn’t seem to realise she is going the way of the Left.


Asian Age/ Deccan Chronicle, April 20, 2012

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

"There are few politicians who have made the journey from the sublime to the ridiculous in so short a time as West Bengal’s Mamata Banerjee."

I disagree. Power corrupts. It is an age old tradition in "democratic" India. When institutions are fragile and people are weak, this is the normal course of affairs for politicians. To expect anything else would be naive.

Rakhaliya said...

It was very predictable sir in your analysis of the Bengali "Agnikonya". Expected something more novel and incisive from you.

Anonymous said...

I think Mamata Bannerjee is on the right track. For decades, the people of Poschimbongo have been conditioned to believe that constant "revolution" is the way to deliverance. They are not interested in "development".

That is why Mamata Bannerji came to power on the back of gono-andolan and dharna. She is fully aware that constant agitation is the way to stay in power. She has learnt her lesson well from Jyoti Basu. People like Buddhadev Bhattacharya have no place in the politics of Poschimbongo.

Pattabhi Ram said...

When I told you once that not much can be expected of a lady who does not know how to drape a sari, you had taken offense.

Anonymous said...

Why do we Indians expect one person alone to wave a magic wand & deliver everything right?

As you had rightly observed earlier Gujarat's prosperity is ALSO due to the quality of Gujaratis. Sri.Narendra Modi himself said that in an interview. That they are hardworking , enterprising , aspiring for good quality of life & don't relish free doles & undeserved subsidies.

That way I would say South Indians are excessively besotted with filmstars & torrid movies.

Kerala & West Bengal always enjoy wallowing in poverty & deprivation. That is considered "intellectualism" by them.

Exceptions prove the rule.

Why did Swami Vivekananda travel to America ? He saw through the "intellectual opium eaters".

Anonymous said...

Why do we Indians expect one person alone to wave a magic wand & deliver everything right?

As you had rightly observed earlier Gujarat's prosperity is ALSO due to the quality of Gujaratis. Sri.Narendra Modi himself said that in an interview. That they are hardworking , enterprising , aspiring for good quality of life & don't relish free doles & undeserved subsidies.

That way I would say South Indians are excessively besotted with filmstars & torrid movies.

Kerala & West Bengal always enjoy wallowing in poverty & deprivation. That is considered "intellectualism" by them.

Exceptions prove the rule.

Why did Swami Vivekananda travel to America ? He saw through the "intellectual opium eaters".

One of my Bengali Professors in Kolkata told the students:-

" Majority of Bengalis want to hold on to Rabindranath Tagore's beard & thus bask in reflected glory".

Someone asked Sri.Ramana Bhagavan to place a hand on his head as Sri.Ramakrishna Paramahamsar had on Vivekananda thus making him see God.

After a pregnant pause Bhagavan asked softly:-

" Do you think you are Vivekananda?"

Anonymous said...

Why do we Indians expect one person alone to wave a magic wand & deliver everything right?

As you had rightly observed earlier Gujarat's prosperity is ALSO due to the quality of Gujaratis. Sri.Narendra Modi himself said that in an interview. That they are hardworking , enterprising , aspiring for good quality of life & don't relish free doles & undeserved subsidies.

That way I would say South Indians are excessively besotted with filmstars & torrid movies.

Kerala & West Bengal always enjoy wallowing in poverty & deprivation. That is considered "intellectualism" by them.

Exceptions prove the rule.

Why did Swami Vivekananda travel to America ? He saw through the "intellectual opium eaters".

One of my Bengali Professors in Kolkata told the students:-

" Majority of Bengalis want to hold on to Rabindranath Tagore's beard & thus bask in reflected glory".

Someone asked Sri.Ramana Bhagavan to place a hand on his head as Sri.Ramakrishna Paramahamsar had on Vivekananda thus making him see God.

After a pregnant pause Bhagavan asked softly:-

" Do you think you are Vivekananda?"

Kamal Upadhyay said...

Didi also knows that she is going left's way but we have to see why she is doing that.
http://kamalupa.blogspot.in/
@kamalupa

Dinesh Divekar said...

Dear Swapanda,

Excellent piece of article. You have written in your characteristic style. However, what is missing is comments on future. What will be the scenario in 2016? Columnist is supposed to write about future too. That was missing.

What you have writtten that everybody knows only the thing your language is very standard. But then that is not sufficient. Strength of thought should get primacy over strength of wordpower.

Regards,

Dinesh V Divekar

D said...

A witty retort on NDTV says it all, when Derek O Brien claimed 2016-2021 will be an excellent year for Mamta as CM of PB, someone exclaimed Thank God we are safe ...she will not be the PM of India

Anonymous said...

The name Derek O Brien brings to my mind the following.

In Bournvita Quiz contest a school from Chennai gave the correct answer for a question asked as 'soccer'. But the boy pronounced it as 'saucer'. Though the supersmart Derek knew it disqualified him saying " what? saucer??..can't give it to you".

On another occasion the question posed was:-

" Who gets admitted in a hospital where no disease is involved ".

The right answer according to Derek was " a pregnant woman ".

But one of the students gave a brilliant reply :-

" Politicians ".

Predictably he was disqualified.

Thus by default Derek helped me in getting over this fascination for quiz contests.